The bible’s story of David and Goliath created a symbol of good triumphing over evil that influenced years of commissioned art in the city of Florence Italy. In 1 Samuel 17, the Israelites are being defeated by the Philistine warriors, and nobody will challenge the Philistine’s huge warrior Goliath in battle. A young shepherd comes forward and triumphs over Goliath using a slingshot and the huge warrior's own sword (Fairchild) The city of Florence, surrounded by warring neighbors and the internal powerful Medici family, came to see David as representing the underdog who triumphs over evil, the symbol of their own city. Three statues of David commissioned in Florence by two artists Donatello and Michelangelo demonstrate the importance of this symbol to the city. Yet these three statues have their own unique symbolism, their history and unique visual appearance tell a lot about the political and cultural climates they were created within.
Donatello was commissioned to carve a marble David in 1408 by the Operai of the Cathedral of Florence. The Cathedral was the heart of the city. Lavish programs of public sculpture and campaigns of building and decoration were going on in Florence. Historians often date the beginning of the Renaissance to these buildings and decorations being constructed (Wilk). The statue was never erected in the Cathedral; the Signoria of Florence commanded it go to their palazzo, at the civic heart of the city. Perhaps the politicians of the time knew the statue was an effective political symbol. In a similar move, a second Donatello bronze statue of David, commissioned by the powerful Medici family for their palace in Florence, was ordered moved to the Palazzo when the Medici’s were exiled in 1494. To illustrate yet again the Florentine politicians’ acknowledgment of the “ownership” of the David image, Michelangelo’s marble statue of David was originally commissioned by the Florence Cathedral to be displayed along the roofline and never made it into the church. The statue was placed in a public square, outside the Palazzo del Signoria.
The terms Renaissance and Humanism often go hand in hand. Paul Oskar Kristeller, a Renaissance humanist scholar, views humanism as the central intellectual movement of the renaissance. He identifies the term as a “Broad cultural and literary movement” with “important philosophical implications and consequences”, no shared philosophical doctrine except “a belief in the value of man and the humanities and in the revival of ancient learning” (Gouwens 58). Donatello’s first marble David was an early commission (Donatello's Marble David). The statue does not show a lot of innovation. David’s face is expressionless; he does not even seem to notice his decapitated foe lying at his feet. His second bronze David was a controversial work of art. The nude boy seems almost effeminate, and he is wearing a hat and boots, who makes his nudity, appear bizarre and untraditional. The statue has a unique style, departing from the strict traditional form of Roman or Greek origin, reflecting the growing focus on individualism apparent in Humanist art.
Michelangelo’s marble David is not depicted with the slain head of Goliath-like Donatello's two sculptures. The statue is calm, and of the three statues most closely resembles the heroic Greek nude, an example of the rediscovery of classical antiquity popular in the late Renaissance period (Levine). These three statues of the same biblical David, visually illustrate the political and cultural climates of the changing Humanist and Renaissance period they arrive in, and their artists place within that history.
Berstein, Mary. "Donatello's "Gattamelata" and It's Humanist Audience." Renaissance Quarterly 55.3 (2002): 883-868. JSTOR. Web. 20 Sept. 2013.
"Donatello's Marble David." Donatello's Marble David. N.p., n.d. Web. 21 Sept. 2013. http://faculty.cua.edu/pennington/churchhistory220/Donatello1.
Fairchild, Mary. "David and Goliath - Bible Story Summary About David and Goliath." Christianity - About Christianity and Living the Christian Life. N.p., n.d. Web. 21 Sept. 2013. http://christianity.about.com/od/biblestorysummaries/p/davidandgoliath.
Gouwens, Kenneth. "Perceiving the Past: Renaissance Humanism After the "Cognitive Turn"." The American Historical Review 103.1 (1998): 55-82. JSTOR. Web. 21 Sept. 2013.
Levine, Saul. "Michelangelo's Marble David and the Lost Bronze David: The Drawings." Artibus et Historiae 5.9 (1984): 91-120. JSTOR. Web. 20 Sept. 2013.
Wilk, Sarah Blake. "Donatello's Dovizia as an Image of florentine Political Propaganda." Artibus et Historiae 7.14 (1986): 9-28. JSTOR. Web. 19 Sept. 2013.